Parkinsn's Email List Message

Posting to the Parkinsn List is a benefit of Subscription


[Message Prev][Message Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Message Index][Thread Index]

Re: Dr. Ray Strand's diet helps or what?


Hi Joe: Is this the same GM1 ganglioside that they are
using in clinical trials at Thomas Jefferson in
Philadelphia?        Carole H.

--- "J. R. Bruman" <jrbruman@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> Michel Margosis wrote:
> > 1) 'Natural Substances' have not been
> scientifically proven that
> > they are safe and efficacious, in the manner the
> Code of Federal > > Regulations prescribe for human
> drugs.
>
> Make no mistake, the 'natural substances',
> 'nutrition supplements'
> or whatever, sold without FDA approval, may be
> DRUGS, and potent ones
> at that. The big difference between those and the
> drugs approved by the
> FDA for prescription by doctors is that the former
> have not passed the
> rigorous, formal, placebo-controlled testing
> required by the FDA. Many
> of the 'approved' drugs are also derived from
> natural sources, and the
> reason why or how they work may be poorly
> understood, if at all. There
> may be different reasons for marketing a
> 'supplement' that lacks FDA
> approval: Perhaps it's just snake oil, and the
> owners know it. Or maybe
> they don't want to gamble the huge investment in the
> approval process.
> Or perhaps they simply don't survive the stringent
> trial. Ganglioside
> GM-1 is a popular example: After selling it in
> health food stores for
> a long time, the owners started an FDA-type trial a
> few years ago, but
> I haven't seen any published results since then;
> maybe it's too early.
> The other difference between approved drugs and diet
> supplements is
> the latter need not meet rigid production standards
> of potency and
> purity. But some supplements, such as vitamins, are
> quite reliable.
> The main government restriction on supplement
> marketers is that they
> aren't allowed to lie in their advertised claims,
> and some of the
> elaborate circumlocutions that result can be
> unintentionally funny.
> Cheers,
> Joe
>
> --
> J. R. Bruman   (818) 789-3694
> 3527 Cody Road
> Sherman Oaks, CA 91403-5013
>


=====

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Bid and sell for free at 


Parkinsn's List Subject Index

Parkinsn's List Thread Index

Parkinsn's Archive Treasures Doctors, students, patients and caregivers find current Parkinson's information such as the Algorithm, Caregivers Handbook, and talks by respected Movement Disorder Specialists.

Mail converted by MHonArc 2.6.10
Site Hosting donated by He.net
&
Grant from The Parkinson Alliance